Finding the Right Buyer: Looking Beyond the Obvious Acquirer

Finding the Right Buyer: Looking Beyond the Obvious Acquirer

By Jay Tapp and Vijay Tirathrai, Managing Directors, STS Capital Partners 

Ask most business owners who they believe would acquire their company, and a familiar list often emerges: a leading competitor, an established industry player, a longstanding supplier, or a private equity firm that has previously expressed interest. 

While these may be logical starting points, limiting the search to familiar buyers can significantly constrain the value an owner ultimately realizes. 

The buyer willing to pay the greatest premium may be one the owner has never considered. They may operate in another industry, compete in a different geography, or recognize strategic opportunities that are not immediately apparent to the business owner. 

Identifying that buyer requires looking beyond traditional industry boundaries to understand where a business can create the greatest strategic value.

Looking Beyond Traditional Valuation 

For most business owners, selling their company is a once-in-a-lifetime event. While they understand their business better than anyone, that familiarity can influence how they perceive its value and who they believe might acquire it. 

Owners often anchor their expectations to familiar industry multiples, comparable transactions, or interest from known buyers. This creates what we refer to as multiple bias, where conventional valuation benchmarks can limit expectations before a sale process has even begun. 

At STS Capital Partners, we believe achieving an Extraordinary Exit™ begins with uncovering the unique strategic value within a business, including assets and capabilities that may not be fully reflected in traditional financial statements. 

We call these Rembrandts in the Attic. 

They may include longstanding customer relationships, proprietary technology, specialized expertise, trusted brands, or an established presence in markets that are difficult to enter. 

While an owner may view these as ordinary parts of their business, the right strategic acquirer may recognize an opportunity to accelerate growth, enter new markets, or acquire capabilities that would otherwise take years to develop. 

Importantly, these assets hold different value for different buyers. One acquirer may place a significant premium on proprietary technology, while another may value an established distribution network or specialized workforce. 

This is the foundation of Selling to Strategics™: identifying the buyers who stand to gain the greatest strategic advantage from an acquisition and positioning the business to demonstrate that value. 

Identifying the Right Strategic Buyer

Finding the right buyer requires more than developing a list of companies operating in the same industry. 

At STS, we take a global, industry-agnostic approach to buyer identification, beginning with a fundamental question: Which organizations stand to gain the greatest strategic advantage from acquiring this business? 

Answering that question often reveals potential acquirers beyond the owner’s immediate competitive landscape, including: 

  • Adjacent industries: Companies seeking to expand their offerings, strengthen customer relationships, or enter complementary markets. 
  • Global strategic buyers: International organizations looking to accelerate geographic expansion through an established business. 
  • Organizations pursuing transformation: Companies seeking capabilities, technologies, or expertise that support their long-term strategic objectives. 
  • Businesses across the value chain: Suppliers, distributors, or customers that could strengthen their competitive position through an acquisition.
Infographic showing four types of potential business buyers.

By looking across industries and leveraging global relationships, STS can identify strategic buyers whose acquisition priorities may not be apparent through a conventional sale process. 

As Vijay Tirathrai, Managing Director at STS Capital Partners, puts it: 

“For most founders, this is the first time they’ve sold a business, and they naturally anchor on the buyers and multiples they already know. Part of our role is to open up the mind of the seller. We start by mind-mapping all of the potential buyers, not just the obvious ones, and that changes the way we go about the entire buying exercise.” 

Consider Project Marathon, where STS advised the founder of a consulting, technology implementation, and support services company built over more than two decades. 

The founder had established an ambitious exit objective that other advisors suggested would be difficult to achieve. Through strategic buyer identification and a disciplined, competitive sale process, STS generated seven offers, ultimately achieving a valuation exceeding twice the founder’s original stretch objective. 

The outcome demonstrates how expanding the buyer universe and creating competitive tension can significantly influence the value realized at exit. 

Turning Strategic Value Into an Extraordinary Exit™ 

Some of the most compelling strategic acquirers may have little awareness of a business or the opportunity it represents. Reaching them requires understanding their growth priorities, developing a compelling acquisition rationale, and engaging the senior decision-makers who can recognize the strategic opportunity. 

For most founders, navigating this process while continuing to lead their business is exceptionally challenging. 

An experienced sell-side M&A advisor brings the perspective, relationships, and transaction expertise necessary to identify opportunities that might otherwise remain undiscovered and create a competitive environment that maximizes value. 

As Jay Tapp, Managing Director at STS Capital Partners, explains: 

“Owners know the business they’ve built. But the right buyer may be in another part of the world or in a different industry, and they may see something the owner doesn’t. It could be a faster route to market, trusted customer relationships, or a capability that would take years to build. Our job is to find that global strategic buyer and make the value clear.” 

Ultimately, selling a business is about more than achieving an attractive purchase price. It is about finding an acquirer who recognizes what the owner has built, values its future potential, and can support the continued success of its people and legacy. 

The most obvious buyer may offer familiarity, but the right strategic buyer may deliver an outcome far beyond traditional expectations. 

An Extraordinary Exit™ begins by looking beyond the obvious. 

To explore how STS Capital Partners can help identify the right strategic buyer for your business, visit stscapital.com. 


Jay is an entrepreneur and international business leader who has founded four businesses and built, scaled, and exited companies over a career spanning more than 30 years. His experience encompasses acquisitions, operational turnarounds, and strategic international divestitures across plastics, polymers, packaging, and printing, bringing a firsthand owner’s perspective to the complexities of business growth and exit planning. 

Vijay is an entrepreneur, investor, and strategic advisor with more than 35 years of experience spanning family businesses, venture capital, technology, and infrastructure. He brings expertise in M&A strategy, founder-led exits, and cross-border transactions. Previously Managing Director and Regional Head of MENAPT at Techstars, he led investments in more than 70 companies over seven years, combining firsthand business-building experience with an international investor’s perspective.